I reckon your general idea is
, and I can't beleive someone hasn't made a
western mmorpg yet. As for your skills idea, I think it should be more Oblivon style. If you use a lot of pistols, you get better with pistols, rifles better with rifles, tomahawks and melee weapons better with melee, but no disadvantages to using other weapons - I hate that.
But instead of Oblivion style, I reckon you should have
ol' xp as well, to put up stuff like 'dexterity', 'strength' and so on. I remember mapping all my skills in Oblivion to make a guy with max stats, and it was painful.
For races, I think you should go with American, Mexican, and Native American, with sub-types for each, like Sioux, Texan, ect. each having attribute bonus's and such.
horse idea, and I think everything should be fully customisable too, or at least with facials.
You should have some kind of
/
thing going, but I wouldn't like to look completely ugly just cause I'm a complete ***. I'd go for FPS just cause you can make the fighting a lot more dependable on th person playing that way, and then you don't get people who have high stats/skills owning people who are actually
gamers.