in
Welcome to Lionhead Community Sign in to Windows Live ID | Help

So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

Last post 09-20-2009, 2:26 by Rendar666. 63 replies.
Page 1 of 3 (64 items)   1 2 3 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  06-03-2009, 17:52 3361443

    So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

     Woody gives us a link to a Pete quote saying, essentially, he has faith in the human race that we won't abuse a fake, not real, not actually alive kid named Milo.

    Grand Theft Auto.
    Fable 2 (dog abuse anybody?)
    Every RTS, RPG, FPS ... in the history of all eternity.

    Plus Japanese rape simulators. Smoker [:zmoker:]

    Hell, the human race has a hard enough time not abusing and killing and raping folks that actually breath.

    And the best response Pete and Woody have is to tell us we will be G o o d [Good] to Milo and to lock a thread that tried to have a serious conversation about it?

    Can you at least say he won't respond to us trying to have virtual sex with him or something? That he won't understand curse words and won't be able to recognize penises? Seriously.

     You're trying to impress upon us how super-advanced and post-sci-fi all this is Milo hee haw is, with the one caveat that we can't starve him or make him kill himself or drown him or burn his house down or kick his dog.

     I'm not saying I even really want to do these things, but I think it's absolutely ri-frggin'-diculous you're trying to keep everyone from talking about it. Obviously people want to talk about.

     I don't even want to talk about, I want to talk about how you don't want people to talk about it.
  •  06-03-2009, 18:01 3361449 in reply to 3361443

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    I agree it is pretty childish in a way, to simply lock all discussions on the matter. Can't just sweep it under the rugs chaps, and none of us are going to be doing such acts, so I still see no reason to lock these topics.

    Not like it's a case of "list your top ten sexual things you'l do to Milo" thread.

    http://automission.deviantart.com/
  •  06-03-2009, 18:01 3361450 in reply to 3361443

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    I agree. The closure seemed very...premature. And the website certainly didn't help to answer any questions, it just made me sad to know how far off humanity is from PMs optimistic opinion of us. Sad [:(]

    Anyway, I'm sure these questions will get addressed one way or another. I mean, apparently the first thought many people had was "Can I (or someone else) do something sexually explicit around this kid?" so they'll have to address it eventually...


    EDIT: This would have been a much better link to close the last thread on. It doesn't explain everything, but it does address a few of the questions we've been asking.

    LINK


    Futurama is back, baby. Complete with the original cast!


  •  06-03-2009, 18:58 3361463 in reply to 3361450

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    In either case...my topic was more about condemning the notion of negative behaviour towards milo...no condoning. There was no need to lock the thread.
  •  06-03-2009, 19:09 3361465 in reply to 3361450

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    ErodeTheSoul:


    EDIT: This would have been a much better link to close the last thread on. It doesn't explain everything, but it does address a few of the questions we've been asking.

    LINK


     Thought the same thing when I saw that.

     Regardless, it's not just about sexy parts. It's about how we can treat him, discipline him, etc. "Milo, you're friggin' retarded, how could you fail this test? You want a bike because Alex got a bike? You can't have one, because Alex isn't retarded. You, however, are ... and retards can't ride bikes."

     Would Milo clam up and turn into the Child Called It?
  •  06-03-2009, 19:10 3361466 in reply to 3361463

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    yohance:
    There was no need to lock the thread.


    Agreed. Seeing as how he was hasty in his closing of the first thread, Woody may reopen the thread, or let us say our peace here. ^^ [^^] Who knows? The mods doth work in mysterious ways!

    EDIT:
    The_Orcid:


     Thought the same thing when I saw that.

     Regardless, it's not just about sexy parts. It's about how we can treat him, discipline him, etc. "Milo, you're friggin' retarded, how could you fail this test? You want a bike because Alex got a bike? You can't have one, because Alex isn't retarded. You, however, are ... and retards can't ride bikes."

     Would Milo clam up and turn into the Child Called It?


    LOL Laugh [:laugh:] *** dude, that's terrible! Funny, though. I get your point, too. I wouldn't talk to him like that (I'm creeped out by how real he seemed via video; I couldn't imagine saying things like that "face-to-face", so to speak) but I guarentee every single one of my friends will, and I'm intrigued to know how he would respond.


    Futurama is back, baby. Complete with the original cast!


  •  06-03-2009, 19:14 3361469 in reply to 3361466

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    judging by that interview, (Which I did find for all of us btw Stick out tongue [:P]) Milo does seem to be pretty much smoke and mirrors, we just get a chance to say a few things. I can see this working like current games.

    You select dialogue, or in this case, say some dialogue, he reacts with what is essentially a cutscene, then you get a chance to talk again, rinse repeat.

    No such fun as free form chats as I had hoped. But I still do hold hope for the game to be updated and so on.


    Besides, we don't need to abuse Milo. Pc modders will make their own "porn game" and child abuse games that will use the Natal via their pc, etc. I think the odds of them not doing so are a million to one.

    http://automission.deviantart.com/
  •  06-03-2009, 23:50 3361544 in reply to 3361469

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    Saying things let alone doing things to the poor virtual kid seems kinda out there. Firstly I would be paranoid doing anything in front of a constant streaming motion camera which catches everything I do and being connected to Xbox LIVE, I'm sure privacy is ensured but I just won't take that chance. Secondly, I always form some sort of connection with a character and treat other characters accordingly. For example I always did what was right in Fable II not because I wanted to be the "G o o d [Good] Guy" but because I felt naturally inclined to do so, (Unless an Achievement was Involved), Whether this Milo was Atari looking or natural as he is depicted, I would react as I would normally do so and not make the system compute me as a "Bad Guy." Thirdly, I wouldn't setup camera's 360 hook-ups, and sensors around my room just to insult a kid that doesn't exist all day. I would make the most out of the event and do natural acting like around a normal friend around Milo. And last...Finally us Geeky Gamers can Purchase a Friend that Understands Our Feelings!!! Big Smile [:D]


    "Wisdom is knowing what to do next; Skill is knowing how to do it, and Virtue is doing it."

    [Follow me on Twitter: @mystic_wolf83]
  •  06-04-2009, 0:08 3361553 in reply to 3361544

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    mystic_wolf83:
    Saying things let alone doing things to the poor virtual kid seems kinda out there. Firstly I would be paranoid doing anything in front of a constant streaming motion camera which catches everything I do and being connected to Xbox LIVE, I'm sure privacy is ensured but I just won't take that chance. Secondly, I always form some sort of connection with a character and treat other characters accordingly. For example I always did what was right in Fable II not because I wanted to be the "G o o d [Good] Guy" but because I felt naturally inclined to do so, (Unless an Achievement was Involved), Whether this Milo was Atari looking or natural as he is depicted, I would react as I would normally do so and not make the system compute me as a "Bad Guy." Thirdly, I wouldn't setup camera's 360 hook-ups, and sensors around my room just to insult a kid that doesn't exist all day. I would make the most out of the event and do natural acting like around a normal friend around Milo. And last...Finally us Geeky Gamers can Purchase a Friend that Understands Our Feelings!!! Big Smile [:D]


     Maybe you won't, but I know, if to say I even purchased the game, I would (at some point). If only to see what happens. Not sex him up I mean, but try and turn him into a quivering mute. If not you or me, it'll be someone else. If not someone else, it'll be another somebody. Some Milo, somewhere, is destined for life in the cupboard under the stairs.
  •  06-04-2009, 0:11 3361557 in reply to 3361553

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    The_Orcid:
    mystic_wolf83:
    Saying things let alone doing things to the poor virtual kid seems kinda out there. Firstly I would be paranoid doing anything in front of a constant streaming motion camera which catches everything I do and being connected to Xbox LIVE, I'm sure privacy is ensured but I just won't take that chance. Secondly, I always form some sort of connection with a character and treat other characters accordingly. For example I always did what was right in Fable II not because I wanted to be the "G o o d [Good] Guy" but because I felt naturally inclined to do so, (Unless an Achievement was Involved), Whether this Milo was Atari looking or natural as he is depicted, I would react as I would normally do so and not make the system compute me as a "Bad Guy." Thirdly, I wouldn't setup camera's 360 hook-ups, and sensors around my room just to insult a kid that doesn't exist all day. I would make the most out of the event and do natural acting like around a normal friend around Milo. And last...Finally us Geeky Gamers can Purchase a Friend that Understands Our Feelings!!! Big Smile [:D]


     Maybe you won't, but I know, if to say I even purchased the game, I would (at some point). If only to see what happens. Not sex him up I mean, but try and turn him into a quivering mute. If not you or me, it'll be someone else. If not someone else, it'll be another somebody. Some Milo, somewhere, is destined for life in the cupboard under the stairs.


    I'm sure such as ALICE software works, any inappropriate comments or unknown phrases will be ignorared or he will change the subject. For example if you told him, "Go die you little brat and burn your house down while you're at it."...He would probably say, "Sounds Like fun, by the way that's a nice shirt you're wearing, where'd you get it?"


    "Wisdom is knowing what to do next; Skill is knowing how to do it, and Virtue is doing it."

    [Follow me on Twitter: @mystic_wolf83]
  •  06-04-2009, 0:15 3361559 in reply to 3361557

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    mystic_wolf83:
    The_Orcid:
    mystic_wolf83:
    Saying things let alone doing things to the poor virtual kid seems kinda out there. Firstly I would be paranoid doing anything in front of a constant streaming motion camera which catches everything I do and being connected to Xbox LIVE, I'm sure privacy is ensured but I just won't take that chance. Secondly, I always form some sort of connection with a character and treat other characters accordingly. For example I always did what was right in Fable II not because I wanted to be the "G o o d [Good] Guy" but because I felt naturally inclined to do so, (Unless an Achievement was Involved), Whether this Milo was Atari looking or natural as he is depicted, I would react as I would normally do so and not make the system compute me as a "Bad Guy." Thirdly, I wouldn't setup camera's 360 hook-ups, and sensors around my room just to insult a kid that doesn't exist all day. I would make the most out of the event and do natural acting like around a normal friend around Milo. And last...Finally us Geeky Gamers can Purchase a Friend that Understands Our Feelings!!! Big Smile [:D]


     Maybe you won't, but I know, if to say I even purchased the game, I would (at some point). If only to see what happens. Not sex him up I mean, but try and turn him into a quivering mute. If not you or me, it'll be someone else. If not someone else, it'll be another somebody. Some Milo, somewhere, is destined for life in the cupboard under the stairs.
    I'm sure such as ALICE software works, any inappropriate comments or unknown phrases will be ignorared or he will change the subject. For example if you told him, "Go die you little brat and burn your house down while you're at it."...He would probably say, "Sounds Like fun, by the way that's a nice shirt you're wearing, where'd you get it?"


     And where does it end?

    "Milo, Alex is better than you."
    "Milo, you're ugly."
    "Milo, your dog has cancer."

    I can suck all the sunshine out of his little virtual life without spewing bile outright. If Milo can't even recognize a negative comment, then the whole point of this fancy-schmancy technology is moot and out the window.  

    And this is right off the top of my noggin, substantial though it may be. A truly devious *** is gonna concoct some nefarious plot I can scarcely now imagine.
  •  06-04-2009, 0:20 3361561 in reply to 3361559

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    Who is this Alex character you keep talking about?

    Also, what's the thing with the dog being called Kate? Did somebody at the LH staff recently get jilted by a female with coincidentally the same name?

    I only wrote this because I hate you.
  •  06-04-2009, 0:25 3361564 in reply to 3361561

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    LethargicMotivator:
    Who is this Alex character you keep talking about?

    Also, what's the thing with the dog being called Kate? Did somebody at the LH staff recently get jilted by a female with coincidentally the same name?


     Some kid at Milo's school who "always does a bit better than Milo," so sayeth Pete.
  •  06-04-2009, 0:30 3361568 in reply to 3361564

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    Oh wow. Is this Alex a male or a female? Can you instruct Milo to form a romantic relationship with this person?

    Now this brings the real question. What exactly will we be doing with Milo? Are we just talking to him about the minutia of his day until we get bored of him, or he gets bored of us?

    Or can we have real adventures, with him, Kate, and hopefully Claire? Paranoid [:aranoid:]

    Can there be goblins?

    I only wrote this because I hate you.
  •  06-04-2009, 0:34 3361571 in reply to 3361568

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    No silly, we are going to go explore in the Hobbe Cave (such as his shirt foreshadows), and have epic In the Movies scenes while we reinact scenes from Fable and Black and White. Big Smile [:D] Not sure about adventures really, it seems mostly about just interacting with him as he expands in his own little universe, basically he seems to be just a normal friend you would have in your childhood.


    "Wisdom is knowing what to do next; Skill is knowing how to do it, and Virtue is doing it."

    [Follow me on Twitter: @mystic_wolf83]
  •  06-04-2009, 9:47 3361689 in reply to 3361571

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    I dont know, I think it is sad that the first thing everyone thinks of is how many possibilities there would be to abuse a simulated child.

    None of those thoughts ever crossed my mind, I dont know how anyone would ever want to do something like that, or even think about people wanting to. Sad [:(]




  •  06-04-2009, 10:35 3361706 in reply to 3361689

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    dontcountstars:

    I dont know, I think it is sad that the first thing everyone thinks of is how many possibilities there would be to abuse a simulated child.

    None of those thoughts ever crossed my mind, I dont know how anyone would ever want to do something like that, or even think about people wanting to. Sad [:(]



    Thank you! I was called ignorant in the last thread for basically thinking the same way as you. At least I know I'm not alone Crazy [:crazy:]


    Futurama is back, baby. Complete with the original cast!


  •  06-04-2009, 10:40 3361708 in reply to 3361571

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    mystic_wolf83:
    basically he seems to be just a normal friend you would have in your childhood.


    That is how I seen it as well. and that is a G o o d [Good] point. To address the topic at hand.  Whatever reason Woody has for closing those topics, I personally respect it and agree with him.


  •  06-04-2009, 11:04 3361714 in reply to 3361708

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    We should definitely be able to discuss how Milo will react to certain situations, be they appropriate or otherwise. So long as the discussions stay relatively on track and not too offensive I see no reason for them to be locked.

    I mean, it's an interesting question. Just how advanced will the ai be? Is his contextual knowledge going to be limited to certain topics? Will those topics be introduced to the player as they're introduced by Milo? Will it be like "Hi, I'm Milo. I like swinging on my tire swing, playing with the fish, jumping on the trampoline, and riding my bicycle. What do you feel like doing today?" and then all recognized phrases and ideas be related to those specific activities?

    Basically, I'm wondering if his scope of reality will be restricted to whatever is going on, and what he has disclosed to you, in his life. Will any other unrecognized topics be met with a reaction based on your tone while speaking? (happy, sad, mad, statement, question etc.)

    While normal people like you or I may comment on his jeans and how cool they look, other people will tell him to take his pants off. Not even in a sexual way, just to see how his programming allows him to react. Would he just nod his head and smile because he registered that you were asking a question in a nice tone of voice?
    We can't cure the world of sorrows, but we can choose to live our lives in happiness.
  •  06-04-2009, 11:18 3361718 in reply to 3361443

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    Correct me if I'm barking up the wrong tree here, straight from the site's list of things resulting in a permanent ban:

    "Posting (images of) or Discussing Extreme Violence and/or Extreme Sexuality;

    Perhaps this is why the thread was locked?
    Large Hadron Collider - because fleshlites are for wusses
  •  06-04-2009, 11:25 3361719 in reply to 3361714

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    Even though the possibilty of people trying to exploit and abuse Milo, sexually or otherwise, is ... discomfitting, to say the least, isn't it better to abuse virtual boy who isn't actually real and therefore can't suffer any negative effects than some real kid down the street? 
    Yes, I thought so. Just watch your step or I'm totally telling.
  •  06-04-2009, 11:27 3361721 in reply to 3361718

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    alecunlimited:
    Correct me if I'm barking up the wrong tree here, but I suppose when almost a quarter of a million people have viewed the introductions thread in OT, yet only 5,878 have viewed the rules thread, I guess it's no surprise; straight from the site's list of things resulting in a permanent ban:

    "Posting (images of) or Discussing Extreme Violence and/or Extreme Sexuality;

    Perhaps this is why the thread was locked?


    Well we are talking about a game here and I would hardly call it extreme, you can starve people to death on the sims you can drown them set them on fire.
    You can decapitate people in most games you can blow their heads off.
    I guess people just crap themselves when someone mentions any of this happening to children no matter what context it's put in.

    I've already had one post deleted in this forum when someone said along the lines of not to shoot the game down before its out .

    To which I quoted and replied "Can we shoot him in the game Crazy [:crazy:]" I didn't see anything bad about this as it was (fairly) obviously a joke, but it was deleted and when I messaged the moderator asking why, they still haven't got back to me (Wont mention who deleted).

    Like I said people just crap themselves at the thought of harming children in anyway and how it reflects on the company.

    PM me if you want an invite to lockerz!
  •  06-04-2009, 11:33 3361726 in reply to 3361721

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    But surely the thread was discussing pedophilia, which is extreme sexuality n'est pas?
    Large Hadron Collider - because fleshlites are for wusses
  •  06-04-2009, 11:36 3361727 in reply to 3361726

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    alecunlimited:
    But surely the thread was discussing pedophilia, which is extreme sexuality n'est pas?

    Possibly, probably not the best word to use pedophilia

    PM me if you want an invite to lockerz!
  •  06-04-2009, 11:50 3361734 in reply to 3361727

    Re: So why is every post and thread about Milo abuse getting deleted or locked (genuine discussion thread inside!)

    sim656:
    alecunlimited:
    But surely the thread was discussing pedophilia, which is extreme sexuality n'est pas?

    Possibly, probably not the best word to use pedophilia


    I thought the thread in question was the one titled "Sad mental state of today's gamers (pedophilia)" that Woody locked?
    Large Hadron Collider - because fleshlites are for wusses
Page 1 of 3 (64 items)   1 2 3 Next >
View as RSS news feed in XML