Needs of Many. I should have picked love because I couldn't complete any of the archaeologist quests, or the Lady Grey quest. Also, I know it is also supposed to be a selfless act, but this reward could have been obtained by just being
![G o o d [Good]](/emoticons/g_o_o_d.gif)
(All you have to do is donate 250 gold to the temple of light 30 times). It would've been nice to see communites grow as a result to you bringing back the dead.
I also think the Needs of One is a really weak choice for an
![E v i l [Evil]](/emoticons/e_v_i_l.gif)
character. If you really have an
![E v i l [Evil]](/emoticons/e_v_i_l.gif)
character, you can just buy everything and set the prices/rent to 100% and make a million in a day or two. If I am
![E v i l [Evil]](/emoticons/e_v_i_l.gif)
(which I was in my first play-through), I am not going to want money. I am going to want to make everyone fear me, and respect me through intimidation. The one thing the would have been perfect (at least to me being an
![E v i l [Evil]](/emoticons/e_v_i_l.gif)
character) would have been to take control of the Shadow Courts. The Spire is off limits because Theresa *claims* it for herself.
Also, if we can destroy oakfield, why can't we destroy Westcliff. The one thing I didn't like about destroying oakfield is what it looked like after. I didn't mind it looking all gloomy and all that, but it would have been awesome to see shadow worshipers in Oakfield. It would also have been cool to see them to build a new center where the ToL was. Eh, sorry about going on about that, I realize that this was supposed to be about the main choice.
Love is the best choice IMO. You can easily earn the two other choices, and you get the dog back. Also, the letter from Rose also adds more to the story.